COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF SOFTWARE AND SOFTWARE MODULES DESIGNED FOR ENGINEERING CALCULATIONS AND PHYSICAL PROCESS MODELING

Mamontov O. V.; Yagodkin A. Sergeevich; Evsikova Natalya; Kamalova Nina

doi:doi:10.58168/PHBSc-IT2025_249-256

Home / Conferences / PHYSICAL BASIS OF SCIENCE-INTENSIVE TECHNOLOGIES IN THE MODERN WORLD / PHYSICAL BASIS OF SCIENCE-INTENSIVE TECHNOLOGIES IN THE MODERN WORLD : Proceedings of the All-Russian Scientific and Methodological Conference with International Participation, dedicated to the 80th anniversary of the birth of Professor V.V. Postnikov, timed to the 95th anniversary of VSUFT named after G.F. Morozov

COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF SOFTWARE AND SOFTWARE MODULES DESIGNED FOR ENGINEERING CALCULATIONS AND PHYSICAL PROCESS MODELING

Submit manuscript

To cite

COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF SOFTWARE AND SOFTWARE MODULES DESIGNED FOR ENGINEERING CALCULATIONS AND PHYSICAL PROCESS MODELING

Section: SECTION 2. TECHNOLOGIES. SCIENCE. YOUTH

Proceedings: PHYSICAL BASIS OF SCIENCE-INTENSIVE TECHNOLOGIES IN THE MODERN WORLD : PROCEEDINGS OF THE ALL-RUSSIAN SCIENTIFIC AND METHODOLOGICAL CONFERENCE WITH INTERNATIONAL PARTICIPATION, DEDICATED TO THE 80TH ANNIVERSARY OF THE BIRTH OF PROFESSOR V.V. POSTNIKOV, TIMED TO THE 95TH ANNIVERSARY OF VSUFT NAMED AFTER G.F. MOROZOV

UDC 681.5

Mamontov O. V. ¹

Yagodkin A. Sergeevich ²

Evsikova Natalya ³

Kamalova Nina ⁴

Author and publication information

Authors:

1. Voronezh State University of Forestry and Technologies named after G.F. Morozov

2. Voronezh State University of Forestry and Technologies named after G.F. Morozov
Russian Federation

3. Federal State Budget Educational Institution of Higher Education «Voronezh State University of Forestry and Technologies named after G.F. Morozov» (obschey i prikladnoy fiziki, zaveduyuschiy kafedroy)
from 01.01.2020 until now Voronezh, Voronezh, Russian Federation

4. FSBE Institution of Higher Education Voronezh State University of Forestry and Technologies named after G.F. Morozov (departmentof General and Applied Physics, Associate Professor)
Voronezh, Russian Federation

Type:

Сonference article

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.58168/PHBSc-IT2025_249-256

Published:

25.08.2025

Subject area:

UDC 681.5

Language:

Russian

Keywords:

multi-criteria comparison method, software, software modules, performing engineering calculations, modeling of physical processes

Abstract and keywords

Abstract (English):
The article provides a comparative analysis of existing software and software modules designed to perform engineering calculations and model physical processes. The method of multi-criteria comparison of alternatives is used for comparison. The criteria for comparison are the functionality of calculations, the possibility of automation and expansion, as well as compatibility with other programs. Within the framework of this approach, it was found that the hybrid CAD/CAE system Autodesk Inventor is optimal.

Keywords:
multi-criteria comparison method, software, software modules, performing engineering calculations, modeling of physical processes

References

1. Panochevnyy, P.N. Primenenie CAD/CAM/CAE tehnologiy v sovremennom mashinostroenii / P.N. Panochevnyy, V.R. Nekrasov // Nauchno-prakticheskie issledovaniya. 2018. – № 3 (12). – S. 128-132.

2. Vozmozhnosti otechestvennyh sistem inzhenernogo analiza (CAE) / V.V. Shelofast, VS. Prokopov, V. V. Shelofast, S.M. Rozinskiy // Sistemy proektirovaniya, tehnologicheskoy podgotovki proizvodstva i upravleniya etapami zhiznennogo cikla promyshlennogo produkta (SAD/CAM/PDM - 2016) : trudy XVI-oy mezhdunarodnoy molodezhnoy konferencii, Moskva, 17-19 oktyabrya 2016 goda. – Moskva: OOO "Analitik", 2016. – S. 19-23.

3. Teoreticheskie osnovy sistemnogo analiza / V.I. Novosel'cev, B.V. Tarasov, V.K. Golikov, B.E. Demin; pod red. V.I. Novosel'ceva. – Moskva: Mayor, 2006. – 592 s.

4. Tochnyy obmen dannymi dlya mul'tifizicheskogo modelirovaniya / Oficial'nyy sayt kompanii «Ansys». – URL: https://www.ansys.com/products/system-coupling (Data obrascheniya 08.04.2025 g.).

5. SOLIDWORKS Simulation / Oficial'nyy sayt kompanii «SOLIDWORKS». – URL: https://www.solidworks.com/ru/product/solidworks-simulation (Data obrascheniya 08.04.2025 g.).

6. Sistema prochnostnogo analiza APM FEM dlya KOMPAS-3D / Oficial'nyy sayt kompanii «APM». – URL: https://apm.ru/apm-fem (Data obrascheniya 08.04.2025 g.).

7. Autodesk Inventor: programmnoe obespechenie dlya 3D-modelirovaniya dlya dizaynerov i inzhenerov / Oficial'nyy sayt kompanii «Autodesk». – URL: https://www.autodesk.com/products/inventor/overview?plc=INVPROSA&;term=1-YEAR&support=ADVANCED&quantity=1&term=1-YEAR&tab=subscription (Data obrascheniya 08.04.2025 g.).

8. Saati, T. Prinyatie resheniy. Metod analiza ierarhiy / T. Saati; per. s angl. R.G. Vachnadze. – Moskva: Radio i svyaz', 1993. – 278 s.

9. Sistemnyy podhod k probleme obosnovaniya modernizacii lesozagotovitel'nyh mashin / P.I. Popikov, N.Yu. Evsikova, N.S. Kamalova, V.S. Polyanin // Aktual'nye napravleniya nauchnyh issledovaniy XXI veka: teoriya i praktika. – 2015. – № 2, ch. 2 (13-2). – S. 296-300.

10. Kuznecov, D.S. Primenenie metoda analiza ierarhiy dlya obosnovaniya vybora naibolee effektivnogo korchevatelya / D.S. Kuznecov, E.V. Pozdnyakov, N.Yu. Evsikova // Voronezhskiy nauchno-tehnicheskiy vestnik. – 2020. – T. 1, № 1 (26). – S. 91-95.

11. Ocenka effektivnosti mehanizmov korchevatel'nyh mashin metodom sravneniya al'ternativ Saati / I.M. Bartenev, E.V. Pozdnyakov, A.K. Pozdnyakov, M.V. Shavkov // Voronezhskiy nauchno-tehnicheskiy vestnik. – 2018. – T. 1, № 1 (23). – S. 91-95.

Submit manuscript

To cite

Citations:

Confirmation

Регистрация